Friday, May 30, 2008

Recent reads

There's been some interesting articles in my media subscriptions lately. Thought I'd use today's post to share.

In the June National Geographic, a study of the geology of Stonehenge reveals the source of the monoliths ("polyliths?") there. They came from the Preseli Mountains of Wales. That's a long journey for such big rocks. Also in the same issue is an eye-popping pictorial piece on sea slugs. You must check it out, because it features dozens of David Doubilet images like this one:

WIRED's cover story this month is about environmental "heresies": ideas that supposedly environmentalists aren't supposed to like, but need to happen. The basic premise is that "only cutting carbon matters," and so they come up with some interesting recommendations like: (1) use A/C more, and heating less, (2) "screw the spotted owl" (don't worry about the loss of biodiversity), and (3) buy a used Geo Metro rather than a new Prius. I found this last of particular interest, as it recounts a web rumor that it took less carbon to make a Hummer than a Prius, and therefore Hummers were more environmentally friendly. (The Prius' battery has a lot of high-carbon-cost nickel in it.) WIRED breaks it all down into BTUs, and runs the numbers. According to their analysis, it takes the Prius 100,000 miles to catch up (i.e. be more carbon-efficient) than an old Toyota. Bummer... Big bummer. (At least the Hummer bit has been debunked.)

As usual, Smithsonian had a bunch of interesting pieces in it. Almost everything in there catches my imagination. It's a very well done magazine.

The New Yorker had a couple of articles, too: In their recent "innovators issue," Alex Ross profiled John Luther Adams, the man responsible for the mesmerizing "the place where you go to listen" in the Museum of the North at the University of Alaska, Fairbanks. If you haven't ever been there and find yourself in Fairbanks, I would recommend this museum highly, and this one room / art installation in particular: it plays certain notes and tones and changes the lighting depending on what the aurora, seismic activity, and other Earth processes are doing. And Margaret Talbot profiled Irene Pepperberg, who raised the parrot Alex and taught him to talk. This article explores the insights into intelligence gained from this serendipitous longterm experiment.

On the commodities front, the New York Times reports today that thieving biofuellers are stealing vegetable oil in Oregon, and that guano stocks are being closely guarded in Peru. Telling quote from the latter: "Before there was oil, there was guano, so of course we fought wars over it," (Pablo Arriola).

Labels: , , , , , ,

Thursday, May 29, 2008

What is this object?

A couple of weeks back, out in the Shenandoah Valley, I pulled over to show some students the Oranda Formation (a limey shale which was transitional between Sauk sedimentation and the clastic influence of Taconian mountain-building). But in the midst of my arm-waving, an object caught my eye. On the ground amongst umpteen gazillion slabs of shale was this thing:

object1

What is it? Any ideas? Because I was on a geology field trip, I thought, what kind of fossil is that??? but now I don't think it's a fossil. The grid is too regular, and it lacks a familiar biological symmetry. Could it be some part of a car? It was on the roadside, after all. Each of the little grid squares is 1mm on each side. Here's the side of the object:

object3

You can see the long square-cross-sectioned tubes are bounded by a "shell" of some sort. This "shell" is about 0.5 mm thick. The arc of that curving "shell" suggests it may once have been part of a larger cylindrical shape, with a diameter approximately the same as a 1-liter Nalgene bottle. Lastly, here's an image of the other side (opposite picture #2):

object2

Now that looks like some sort of biological encrustation -- but could it just be slag? There's definitely bubble-like features. My current suspicion is that this is some automobile part that got too hot. This bubbly mess in photo #3 suggests it melted down, perhaps causing the owner to pitch it on the roadside. That sort of waste disposal happens a fair bit in Virginia.

Any ideas what this thing is? Thanks.

Labels: ,

Cruisin' the Fossil Freeway by Kirk Johnson and Ray Troll

In preparation for my time out west this summer, my friend Michelle loaned me her copy of Cruisin' the Fossil Freeway, by Kirk Johnson and Ray Troll. It's a great read, and it's got me really psyched to start driving around the west, looking at geology. It also makes me wish for an informed local guide to clue me in to good outcrops.

I really liked this book. Johnson, a paleontologist with the Denver Museum of Nature & Science, narrates a 5,000-mile roadtrip travelogue about zipping around the western U.S. in search of fossils. Joining Johnson is Troll, a celebrated artist who makes clever art in several media. The book is light-hearted, well-informed, funny, and relaxed. I really liked it, and would recommend it to anyone with an interest in natural history, fossils, roadtripping, or Ray Troll's art.

Coincidentally, Geotimes reviewed the book in their May issue.
...And NPR beat them to it last fall.

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

Cool essay about extinction

Browsing around the web this afternoon, killing time when I should be working on my Geotimes cartoon, I came across this essay on the New York Times website: "Musings inspired by a quagga"*, by Olivia Judson. Good stuff, although I do get tired of hearing that old "but the extinction that caused the death of the dinosaurs wasn't even the biggest" cliche. Inspired by a visit to the Museum National d'Histoire Naturelle in Paris, Judson explores the role of extinction in evolutionary processes. Worth a read.

*By the way, mark your calendars: August 12 is Quagga Day, so proclaimed by Ed Abbey. The one this year is the 125th anniversary of the death of the last quagga.

Labels: ,

Annotated photos from Glacier NP

Cleaning up my hard drive today, before switching over to the laptop for my summer travels. Thought I would share a few annotated photos from my "Geology of Glacier National Park and surrounding areas" class that I took last summer.

Here's Chief Mountain:
chief_mtn

On the trail to Firebrand Pass, here's the contact between the Altyn Formation (lowest of the Belt Supergroup exposed at Glacier) and the overlying Appekunny Formation:
altyn_appekunny

The Purcell Sill is a readily recognizable feature high on the glacially-carved walls of Glacier National Park. This shot is from the trail on the way up to Grinnell Glacier:
sill

Here's a shot from Sun River Canyon, showing one of the many imbricate thrust faults there, with some glacial till thrown in as a bonus feature:
fault

Just outside of Sun River Canyon, we saw some nice recumbent drag folds on some thrust faults in the Cretaceous rocks:
recumbent_anticlines

This one was from early in the trip, on the road from Helena up north towards Glacier. Specifically, we stopped in Little Prickly Pear Canyon, near Wolf Creek, and saw these chevron folds in the Cretaceous rocks there:
anticlines

Along those same lines (folded Cretaceous strata), here's a gorgeous fold just outside the park's boundary, on the road leading north from Two Medicine towards Many Glacier:
big fold

No annotations on this one, but I wanted to share it anyhow: a blind thrust / drag fold complex, in the Grinnell Formation (exposed on the trail up to Grinnell Glacier):
blind_thrust

Lastly, some snow photos. I took this shot on my way up the trail to Grinnell Glacier, because the holes in the snow reminded me of the scary mask face from the Scream movies. But then on the way down, I realized I had the opportunity to document how much snowmelt occurs in six hours of Glacier NP summer weather. Hence, the bottom "after" shot:
snowmelt

That's it for today... Enjoy!

Labels: , , , , , ,

Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Shenandoah geology class

On Saturday, I took a group of NOVA summer school students to Shenandoah National Park to look at some rocks. We had great weather, and saw evidence of Grenvillian mountain building, the breakup of Rodinia, and the transgression of the Sauk Sea. A real crowd-pleaser was an outcrop of what was once columnar basalt (the Catoctin Formation). I say "was once" because the basalt has been metamorphosed to greenstone, and the columns have been squashed into more lathe-like shapes.

Here's a few photos of the columns:






Columns like these form as the cooling mafic lava contracts a bit in volume as it loses heat. This causes a series of fractures to form. The intersection of the fractures defines the hexagonal columns. We've seen the same phenomenon at the Giant's Causeway, Northern Ireland. When the lava of the Catoctin Formation was extruded, Rodinia was breaking up and the Iapetus Ocean was being 'born.' One of the things I really like about the Shenandoah columns is that, even though they're metamorphosed, they show clear 'ribs' on the side -- arrest lines as the propoagating fracture worked its way down into the flow. An inch at a time, the columns grew.
Finally, here's me doing some "arm waving" amongst rapt students (ha!):

All four photos by Nicole LaDue (NSF). Thanks Nicole!

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, May 26, 2008

Audubon geology class goes to DC

Yesterday, I took my Audubon Society / USDA Grad School "Natural History Field Studies" students on a field trip to examine the bedrock geology of Washington, DC. We had a good time: beautiful weather, great attitudes, and even luck with parking! I guess because it's Memorial Day weekend, a lot of people have left town. One of the great challenges of urban geologizing is finding room for those infernal cars...

Here's a photo of the group at Chain Bridge, DC, on Sunday morning:

NHFS_chain_bridge

That class ends on Monday night, bridging the gap between my NOVA spring and summer semesters. It's been a good run -- thanks, folks!

Labels: , , ,

Prius feedback modifies driver technique

An article in today's Washington Post explores the constant feedback that Prius drivers get about their fuel consumption -- and how that may be one of the main reasons that Prii* get lower gas mileage than other vehicles. I've noted this phenomenon before, so I thought I'd pass along a link to the article.

* "Prii" = plural of "Prius," at least in my world.

Labels: , , , ,

Cool new images of Mars

Mars has a new robot geologist on its surface, as of last night at just before 8pm (E.S.T.). The Mars Phoenix lander arrived in Mars' north polar region after an apparently dicey landing sequence that went off without a hitch. It unfurled its solar panels and started taking pictures, like the one at the left. That's a new view of the planet thought most likely to give us insights into the possibility of life elsewhere in the universe.

Why the pole? That's where the water is. Remote sensing indicates ice just a few inches below the surface in this area, and the geomorphology seems to back that up. Visible even in this earliest photo, polygonal shaped features suggest repeated freeze-thaw action. (Similar freze-thaw action in Earth's polar regions produces similar features, like these:



That's the way geology works, right? The principle of uniformity suggests that uniform physical laws operating over vast ranges of time and space will produce similar phenomena in different locations. It remains to be seen how valid this principle is in guiding our exploration of other planets, but with Mars it appears that there are some real similarities. And why do we care where the water is? Because on Earth, all life needs water. Figuring out whether life exists elsewhere in the universe has huge implications for our place in the cosmos.

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, May 24, 2008

WFA Training

Hoo boy! A busy trio of days for me. Thursday and Friday were devoted to an intensive 16-hour Wilderness First Aid training course (WFA). And today I led a twelve-hour field trip to Shenandoah National Park.

As you may recall, I got a grant to cover the tuition for six instructors (four from NOVA, two from Thomas Nelson Community College in Hampton, VA) to get WFA Training. Because he is totally cool, my dean also threw in $500 to cover an additional two instructors from our division on the NOVA-Annandale campus.

So, thanks to the grant and my dean's add-on, eight people who lead field trips for the Virginia Community College System got free Wilderness First Aid training! I'm pretty excited about that. Now, I think we stand a much better chance of saving a student's life if something were to go wrong on a trip.

The training was pretty intensive. Nancy Chamberlain of our Parks & Recreation program organized the event (assisted by geology student Quinn F.), and kept us well fed. The training itself was provided by Wilderness Medical Associates. They did a great job.

Here's the crew:

WFAs

From left to right, that's Victor Zabielski (NOVA-Alexandria), Beth Doyle (NOVA-Alexandria & Annandale), Jen Martin (TNCC), Erik Burtis (NOVA-Woodbridge), Pete Berquist (TNCC), Ken Rasmussen (NOVA-Annandale), me (NOVA-Annandale), and Kirk Goolsby (NOVA-Annandale).

Pete and I are both products of the undergraduate geology program at William & Mary, he in 2001, and I in 1996. Here, Pete splints my simulated "broken leg":

Pete_Callan_WFA_small

(That's the way we are down at William & Mary. We help each other out.)

Do you lead field trips? Do you know what to do if a student breaks a leg? ...or goes into anaphylactic shock? ...or gets a stick through their eyeball? I'm sure glad I have answers to these questions now, and would recommend this (or more?) medical training to anyone who takes students more than 2 hours away from professional medical help. There's some serious @#%* that can go down in the backcountry. I feel like field trip leaders have an obligation to get trained in how to handle that @#%*.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, May 21, 2008

Hackle fringes

A couple days ago, I showed a photo of plumose structure here, a feature that sometimes forms when rocks fracture (i.e. a joint is formed). I invoked the image below to show the relationship between the plumose structures and the concentric "ribs" that sometimes show up on a joint (here labeled as "arrest lines"). The point was to show how they were mututally perpendicular.

But the diagram shows something else, too: that the delicate topography of the plumes becomes more exaggerated away from the main surface of the joint, and they grow into twisted "hackles" along the edge of the joint. Joints have ruffled edges! These hackle fringes can also be spotted on many rock surfaces, if you're looking for them.

Here's a photo I took a couple of weeks ago, in the Silurian Needmore Formation (exposed in the Massanutten Synclinorium between Waterlick, VA and Seven Fountains, VA). It shows a series of hackle fringes parallel to one another, showing the growth of the fracture surface over time.

hackles

Here it is again, with the Photoshop "contrast" dial turned up to 11:

hackles_contrast

The high-contrast view helps bring the hackles into high-relief, and also illuminates the subtle plumose structure. Looks like this surface formed from the top, down. As I read it, this joint started on the right side of the image and propagated leftwards as time went by.

(The hematite nodule at left is a bonus feature.)

Labels: ,

Tuesday, May 20, 2008

Perspectives on coastal tectonics

In December of 2005, I went out to The Sea Ranch, California, for Christmas. (The Sea Ranch is one of those towns that is officially called "The" something, kinda like The Plains, Virginia. Sorta weird, but there it is.) I want to share an experience I had there, because it gave me an important perspective on my own 'native' geology back in the mid-Atlantic region. It was a significant moment of understanding for me. Let me walk you through it...

The following collection of images are what I saw walking a mere 1 mile up and down the coast from the house where we were staying. I hope you will be struck by the incredible diversity of rock types seen here (as I was):

Conglomerate:
IMG_5210_web

IMG_5211_web

Siltstone and shale interbedded (vertical bedding):
IMG_5213_web

Siltstone and shale interbedded (anticline):
IMG_5215_web

Siltstone and shale interbedded (syncline):
IMG_5216_web

Mudchip conglomerate (mud chips are "rip-up" clasts due to scouring of a muddy location by a sudden intense current, which carries much larger particles like the sand that now surrounds the darker, finer-grained mud chips):
IMG_5219_web

Quartz-rich sandstone:
IMG_5221_web

Graywacke (showing mouthwateringly beautiful graded bedding):
IMG_5257_web

A zoomed-out shot of that graded bed:
IMG_5258_web

Various sedimentary layers (sandstone, silstones, shale partings):
IMG_5261_web

And a close-up of a few small faults that cut through them:
IMG_5262_web

And it's not just sedimentary rocks. Here's some greenstone (metamorphosed basalt). Note the cluster of amygdules (infilled vesicles) in the center:
IMG_5223_web

The greenstone is green due to a lot of chlorite, but it also shows some nice epidote:
IMG_5224_web

IMG_5225_web

Looking north up the coast from our rental house, you could see greenstone and conglomerate intermingled on the 10m-scale:
IMG_5244_web

This is in the small cove directly in front of our rental. There are three different rock units seen here (greenstone, conglomerate, clayey sand), all indicating different things. Note the big clast of greenstone "hovering" in the clayey sand part:
IMG_5241_web

IMG_5243_web

So after taking a walk along the lovely coast there, and seeing all this stuff, I thought "Wow."

The tremendous diversity of rock types along this section of the Sonoma County coast was due to tectonic shuffling of rock types at a subduction zone. In the Mesozoic, this part of California was at a trench where the Farallon Plate was being subducted to the east underneath North America. Melting at depth produced magma, which resulted in the Sierra Nevada continental volcanic arc (excellently reviewed by Geotripper in his "Under the Volcano" series examining the Sierras). But at the trench itself, all the sediments at the edge of North America were being compressed and squeezed and mixed up with the sediments being scraped off the subducted oceanic slab. Some knobs and bumps of basalt even got scraped off the Farallon Plate and added into this jumbled mess. Altogether, this big pile of debris from the convergent boundary is referred to as an accretionary wedge. "Accretionary" because it got accreted, or added, onto the western edge of North America. "Wedge" because that's its overall shape in cross-section.

When subduction ceased (due to the subduction of the East Pacific Rise), the Farallon Plate was gone at this latitude, and the Pacific Plate and the North American Plate were now in direct contact for the first time. As time went by, the accretionary wedge reacted to now longer being dragged downward, and it began to isostatically rebound. It bobbed upward, and brought its 'melange' (French for mixture) to the surface. The uplifted accretionary wedge is the California Coast Ranges, a fantastic place for varied geology mainly because of the tectonic "shuffling" that happened here during the Mesozoic.

So, I mentioned that seeing all this diversity in so short a hike really impressed me. But the insight it gave me is that the same thing happened on the east coast. Where I live and work, in DC and Virginia, an accretionary wedge developed during the early Paleozoic, just like in California, with the exception that ours got subsequently squeezed and metamorphosed in a series of mountain-building events. It's a bit more difficult to recognize, partially due to that metamorphism and partially due to all the @#$%ing vegetation obscuring the underlying bedrock. But it's there: we have metagraywacke, with relict graded beds, metabasalt, quartzite, schist ("meta-shale") and metaconglomerate: it's everything I saw in California with a metamorphic overprinting!

"Wow," I thought again.

Here's some shots of DC-area rocks that are analogues for the ones I've already showed you in California:

Metamorphosed mud-chip conglomerate (near Chain Bridge, DC):


Metamorphosed quartz-rich sandstone (the Sugarloaf Mountain quartzite, MD):
sugarloaf_quartzite_veins_web

tension_gash_array_sugarloaf_web

Metagraywacke showing metamorphic chlorite, garnet, and pyrite (both from DC):




Graded bed preserved in metagraywacke (Billy Goat Trail, MD):


Metabasalt (amphibolite, again from the Billy Goat Trail, MD):


Metaconglomerate (Klingle Road, DC):




The experience comparing the two coasts greatly enriched my understanding of tectonics and subduction, and gave me perspective on DC's geologic history. Two different accretionary wedges, two coasts, two eras... but one underlying process. That's what really hit home. Geology repeats itself. It gave me a renewed interest in my local geology. Everyone always hears about what great geology California has (and it does), but doggone it, DC pulled that same trick millions of years earlier, and experienced a series of orogenies immediately afterwards (which California can't claim!).

If it's true that "the best geologist is the one who has seen the most geology," then I became a better geologist that day on the Sonoma coast.

PS - I think it's funny to note that I didn't put a sense of scale in any of the California pictures, but that most of the DC area pictures do have one. I think that says something about my development as a geologist and educator too...

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, May 19, 2008

Plumose structure

Here's a photo one of my Audubon students (Albert) took this past Saturday on the Berma Road, in C&O Canal National Historical Park. The lighting was just right, so that when we passed by this outcrop of metagraywacke, we saw an illuminated example of plumose structure:

plumose

Plumose structure is something that forms when rock breaks. The fracture starts at one point, and then grows, propagating thorough the rock and leaving behind a telling signature of its growth. In this case, the fracture (also known as a joint) started at point A and propagated through the rock to point B (central 'shaft'), expanding laterally (feathery 'plumes') at the same time.

Sometimes, concentric 'ribs' form, perpendicular to all these feathery plumes, showing the actual leading edge of the growing fracture surface. An example most people are probably familiar with is the "clamshell" shape of a classic conchoidal fracture. Check out this image to see how the two relate to one another.

When we saw this lovely example, I pointed out to the students that if we had been there fifteen minutes earlier or later, this subtle topography would either have been obscured totally in shadow, or washed out in full light. It was only because the light was at juuuuuust the right angle relative to these mm-scale variations that we noticed it.

Labels: ,

Sunday, May 18, 2008

Saturday's hike (NOT on the BGT)

On Saturday, I was due to take my Audubon class to the Billy Goat Trail. But, since we had so much rain earlier in the week, the Potomac was running higher than normal, and parts of the trail were flooded, so the Park Service closed it. I was ticked off that I couldn't take my students even on the non-flooded portions of the trail to show them pre-Taconian relict graded beds or Acadian lamprophyre dikes. But the NPS are sticklers for the rules, and there was one hyperenthusiastic volunteer standing guard to make sure we didn't venture onto the trail. So we didn't.

We walked another trail, the Berma Road, instead, which parallels the Washington Aqueduct from Great Falls down to the Old Anglers Inn. Along the way we saw plenty of metagraywacke, migmatite, and granite intrusions. Here's me pretending to 'hold up' up a massive metagraywacke xenolith in the Bear Island Granite:

herculean_xenolith_lifter

We also saw a lot of structure, including boudinage, folds, and faults. While we didn't get to see some of the more striking features of the Billy Goat Trail proper, we made it work okay. And everybody in the class had a great sense of humor in regards to being kept off the BGT itself.

I thought this was a funny form of political protest:

danger_bush_sign

Both photos by Audubon student Paula. Thanks, Paula!

Labels: , , ,

Yellowstone photos

Today, some shots from my time in Yellowstone National Park last summer. Here's Mammoth Hot Springs:

Mammoth Hot Springs, Yellowstone National Park

Close-up of the travertine deposits at Mammoth:

Travertine deposits at Mammoth Hot Springs, Yellowstone

Me advertising my brother's company at Mammoth:

Advertising Connor's company at Mammoth Hot Springs, Yellowstone.

Norris Geyser Basin, slime:

Thermophile bacteria, Norris Geyser Basin

Norris Geyser Basin's loneliest tree:

Norris Geyser Basin's loneliest tree

More slime, this time two colors:

River of two colors of slime

Nasty patch of slime. Looks like snot:

Nasty looking patch of bacteria

Bison herd:

Buffalo

Columnar jointing in basalt:

Columnar basalt

Me showing you where the columnar jointing is. (I'm pointing at it...)

Me pointing out the columnar basalt.

Strata exposed in the Tower area:

Strata

And here they are again, labelled:

Tower area strata, labelled

Lastly, heading north out of Yellowstone back to I-90 and Bozeman, here's a weathered-out Eocene dike in the Paradise Valley. The dike is more resistant to weathering than the rock it cuts through, so it stands up as a "wall"-looking feature.

Eocene dike

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, May 17, 2008

Hyalite Canyon

Every day I'm a day closer to getting back out to Montana. Here's a few photos from a hike I took last summer up to Hyalite Canyon, in the Gallatin Range south of Bozeman. The rocks you see are Eocene-aged volcanics, part of the Absaroka-Gallatin Volcanic Field. Further down in the canyon, there are also metaigneous basement rocks exposed. I collected an amazing three-dimensional folded granite gneiss there. But up at this elevation, I wasn't collecting anything (so I wouldn't have to carry it back down):

Hyalite Canyon below Emerald Lake

Nice wildflowers up there. This is in July:

Wildflowers

And here's the view hiking back down the canyon to the car:

U-shaped valley

It's a classic U-shaped valley, the signature of alpine glacial topography. Here's the Google Maps "terrain" view of this valley:


View Larger Map

Labels: , ,

Friday, May 16, 2008

Volcano monitoring: last night's PGS meeting

Last night I attended my first meeting of the Potomac Geophysical Society (PGS). The PGS meets on Thursday nights, and I usually can't make it because I teach on Thursday nights. (I do however attend meetings of the Geological Society of Washington quite regularly, but those are on Wednesday nights.) Now that the semester is over, I was able to make it to the final PGS meeting of the spring.

The meeting was held at Fort Meyer Officer's Club. It's on a military base adjacent to Arlington National Cemetery, and before entering, my Prius had to be searched for bombs (as did all other civilian vehicles). The Officer's Club was about what you would expect, I guess -- kind of 1950's decor, elegant once. I noticed they had compact fluorescent light bulbs in all the sockets, which pleased me. PGS meetings consist of: (1) beer downstairs in the lounge, (2) dinner upstairs in the "Campaign Room," (3) business details, and (4) a talk by a guest speaker.

Last night's speaker was Bill Burton, from the USGS's volcano hazards and monitoring program. Bill's office will be launching a comprehensive new volcano website later this year, and he gave us a brief preview of its features in last night's talk. If you'd like a look for yourself, they have a beta version of the site online now.

Bill reviewed the efforts of his office to monitor a whole lot of volcanoes in U.S. territory (including the protectorate of the Mariana Islands). The map above shows how they've got their work cut out for them.

I was struck by two things about Bill's talk. First, that the volcanoes that the USGS has fully equipped with monitoring instruments (high-precision GPS, seismographs, etc.) provide a wealth of information which makes it relatively easy (relative to say, earthquakes) to predict eruptions. We've learned enough that we can use subtle signals to issue eruption watches and warnings, for both people on the ground and planes in the air.
But the second thing I noted is that they don't have every volcano in their area of responsibility fully instrumented. In fact, they don't even have every "dangerous" volcano in their areas fully instrumented. A striking example of this was a story Bill told while showing us this image:

That's Cleveland Volcano, one of the Aleutians. The photograph was taken by an astronaut, who then called the duty officer in the Alaska Volcano Observatory and told them "Cleveland's erupting." The AVO doesn't have instrumentation on Cleveland, so this phone call (from space!) was the first they knew about the eruption! That's a pretty big gaping hole in the program, it seems to me. We should know at the very least when our volcanoes are already erupting. Even better would be to fully instrument all our potentially-dangerous volcanoes to the fullest possible extent, so we can predict in advance when they will erupt.

At the end of the talk, I asked Bill about this: "How much more money would your office need to outfit the under-instrumented volcanoes to the level you think they need?" Bill estimated $80 million, both for installation and the constant upkeep these instruments require. This morning on the drive into work, I heard that the new farm bill has $450 million set aside for Chesapeake Bay environmental work, so while $80 million seems like a lot to me, I guess it's not all that much in the grand scheme of things. In a post this morning, Nicholas at The Critical Zone examined this issue of huge numbers, and all the science that could get done with that money.
In the wake of the recent tragedies in Myanmar and China, it seems like the US would be wise to invest some money in outfitting our volcanoes with the full suite of monitoring equipment. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Who knows how many human lives an ounce of seismograph is worth? When a destructive eruption does happen, we're going to wish we had spent that $80 million when we had the chance.

Labels: , , , ,

Scary map du jour

This map was in this morning's Washington Post. The red dots are currently-existing coal-fired power plants. The black dots with the central stars are proposed future coal-fired power plants.
Coal is relatively cheap energy, but it's got some signficant environmental problems associated with it (the accompanying article was about reduced air quality in national parks like Shenandoah). Another recent Washington Post article investigated the effects of mountaintop-removal methods of getting at the coal out in neighboring West Virginia.
More significant than the air quality issue to me is the lunacy of investing more in fossil fuel infrastructure. We should be moving away from these old, dirty technologies, not entrenching ourselves in them. Burning coal generates CO2. The writing is on the wall in regards to the effect of this anthropogenic CO2 on our planetary climate system. But the vast majority of DC's energy comes from coal. Enter the hypocrite: I'm bummed that every time I post to this blog, I'm using electricity that adds carbon to the atmosphere. And if this map is prophetic, it looks like it's going to stay that way for some time to come.

Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, May 15, 2008

800,000 years worth of bubbles

A bunch of articles in today's issue of Nature use precise measurements of the composition of glacial air bubbles to extend the record of atmospheric gases (and airborne dust) back to 800,000 years before present. (Previously, the record "only" went back to 650,000 years before present.) Fully eight glacial cycles are seen in the new, expanded dataset. These new findings are all part of the European Project for Ice Coring in Antarctica (EPICA), and they offer some new insights, as well as additional confirmation of the close link between climate and past fluctuations in CO2 and CH4. Check it out.

Labels: , , ,

Words' worth?

"The beginning of wisdom is to call things by their proper names."
- ancient Chinese proverb

I reckon I'm due for a rant. Here's a list of words that bug me:

Dolomite in place of dolostone: dolomite is a mineral. A huge pervasive second use of the word, however, is to mean a rock made mainly of the mineral dolomite, for which the proper name is dolostone. This is so, so, so common it's hardly noticed. And it's so incorrect. Rocks and minerals are not the same thing.

Orogen in place of mountain belt: the word orogen is technically correct, and quite accurate, but in spoken speech, it sounds too much like "origin," and its use can sow confusion. The only real difference I am able to hear when people say "orogen" is that they tend to pronounce all three syllables, while "origin" is generally pronounced with just two: ore-gin. But maybe that's just the Virginians I hang around with. Mountain belt has the same meaning, but I guess it has problems of its own, since mountain belts may not be topographically mountainous any more. Hmmm. ...Toughie.

Extra-syllable words: Should we say benthonic when benthic means the same thing but with one fewer syllable? What about people orientating themselves instead of orienting themselves? What advantage do these extra syllables provide? Are they vestigial structures in our language?

An educational peeve is that students regularly refer to teachers giving grades. I don't know about the other professors, teachers, and instructors out there, but this one really rankles me. My students earn their grades. What I do is keep track of what they have earned, and eventually assign the proper grade to them. I am merely a secretary, an accountant. I tally it up, but the points they accrue (or don't) depends on them. No gifts required!

A huge bummer is the continued use of theory in non-scientific circles to mean hypothesis. In general use, "theory" has a tenuous, shaky implication, while in science it means "as solid and dependable as an explanation gets." David Quammen explored this well in his discussion of evolution in National Geographic a couple years ago. For the record: a hypothesis is a possible explanation of a phenomenon, calling to be tested. A theory is a well-corroborated hypothesis (i.e. it has passed a great many tests) that coherently unites a number of disparate phenomena under one central explanatory umbrella. Big difference there; huge. Makes communication about important concepts difficult.

Lastly, my all-time least favorite word: Believe.

Everywhere I look, I see statements like "Scientists believe that the Earth formed 4.5 billion years ago," and it drives me up the wall. Scientists infer that the Earth formed 4.5 billion years ago, based on their reliance on data and logic. We have physical evidence (lead isotope ratios from three different radiogenic systems, measured in Earth rocks and in meteorites) that all suggest the solar system's solid-state clock started counting 4.5 billion years ago. Because we've never observed anything other than the steady, statistical decline of radioactive parent isotopes to produce daughter isotopes, we assume that the past worked in the same way as today (actualism/"uniformitarianism") and that these empirical measurements have meaning. We logically deduce that the Earth is the implied age, but we don't "believe" it.

Similarly, I get apoplectic when students ask me "Do you believe in global warming?" No, I don't believe it; I'm convinced of it on the basis of (a) physical evidence (data) and (b) logical inference from that data. To spell it out:
  1. CO2 absorbs infrared radiation.
  2. Infrared radiation is reflected upwards from the surface of the Earth.
  3. CO2 is produced by the burning of coal, oil, natural gas, wood, ethanol, and biodiesel.
  4. We burn a lot of these carbon-rich fuels by oxidizing them.
  5. CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere are measurably increasing.
  6. Oxygen concentrations in the atmosphere are measurably decreasing.
  7. Globally, average temperatures are observed to be increasing.
  8. Therefore, based on #1-7, the increase in CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere is causing the increase in temperature.
There's nothing there to believe in. It just is. Fact, fact, fact, fact, fact, fact, fact, and a logical inference that stems from those facts.

Ditto for the theory of evolution by natural selection. It's not something I believe in; it's something I'm convinced of because it's logically coherent and supported by reams of data gathered over 150 years of hypothesis-testing.

If there is one thing that scientists believe in, it's that the universe makes sense. Our starting assumption is that the physical world operates according to unchanging laws which may be deduced if we're clever enough. On the other hand, if the universe is mercurial in its physical laws, then science doesn't have a chance of figuring things out because the laws that apply on Tuesday will be different from the laws that apply on Wednesday. It should go without saying that, as far as we can tell, this is not the case. The universe does behave in a consistent and predictable manner, insofar as we can tell. Ergo, science is an appropriate way to go about elucidating its structure and properties. No belief necessary.

Which words bug you? Chime in.

Labels: , ,

Farewell My Subaru by Doug Fine

Last week, my friend Michelle loaned me her copy of Farewell, My Subaru, a humorous account of a year spent trying to live locally. The author, Doug Fine, buys a ranch in New Mexico, then converts it to solar power and solar heated water, and raises goats and vegetables. And, yes, he trades in his Subaru for a R.O.A.T. (Ridiculously Oversized American Truck), which runs on vegetable oil. Along the way, he has lots of mishaps (many involving the goats) and finds love, happiness, and satisfaction. In general, he has a nice reflective time of it, accumulating enough experiences and insight to warrant a book. He's also got a great sense of humor. Recommended.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, May 14, 2008

More Massnutten photos

Here's a few more photos from the recent field trip to the Massanutten Synclinorium in the northern Shenandoah Valley, Virginia.

Some more Arthrophycus (?) trace fossils in the Massanutten Formation:

arthophycus

Outcrop of the Massanutten Formation on Route 678, south of Waterlick, VA. Note that the bedding is dipping to the south (reflecting the overall "canoe"-shape to the structure of the Massanutten Synclinorium... this is the "bow" of the canoe...):

massanutten_beds

Shelly horizon in the Mahantango Formation. Mainly brachiopod debris, but also crinoid columnals:

shelly_layer_mahantango

Cross-bedding in the Martinsburg Formation's Bouma sequences. This is a sample I collected on Saturday. I sawed it open on Monday, then polished it and gave it a coat of clear acrylic. Sample length is about 5 cm:

martinsburg_crossbeds_2

Ditto. As above, we can see clear cross-bedding here, reflecting current flow in these ancient turbidites:

martinsburg_crossbeds_1

Bedding / cleavage relationships expressed at an instructive outcrop in the parking lot of a pet store north of Front Royal, Virginia. Bedding is clearly visible running subhorizontally across the picture, but the rock breaks vertically: a tectonically-induced cleavage:

bedding_cleavage

You could hardly ask for a better outcrop to teach bedding / cleavage relationships. Here's a medium-sized anticline in the same outcrop (note quarter, center, for scale). It clearly displays a fan of cleavage orientations. Lovely!

bedding_cleavage_2

Lastly, on that same note, here's a sample I collected fromthat locality, with bedding planes and cleavage planes highlighted through the magic of CorelDraw. The stripes you see on the face of the sample are formed by the intersection of bedding and cleavage planes, shown schematically in red:

bedding_cleavage_3

Labels: , , , , ,

The Palisades Museum of Prehistory

This is how good it is to be a professor on summer break: Yesterday afternoon, after composing yesterday morning's epic account of my Massanutten trip, I toodled on over to the Palisades Museum of Prehistory to (a) drink beer and (b) talk rocks with the museum's curator, Doug Dupin.

The Palisades Museum of Prehistory is in far western Northwest DC, near the Dalecarlia Reservoir and Sibley Hospital. There, you'll find a neighborhood called the Palisades, and in the Palisades, you'll find Doug Dupin's house. In Doug's backyard, you'll find what appears to be a nice shed. Turns out, this is the museum. It's a long story, but basically it boils down to this: Doug was a cartographer, but a contract went sour, and so he was staying at home with a lot of time on his hands. He decided to grow some grapes to make wine, and store that wine in a self-dug wine cellar. He started digging the hole, and encountered arrowheads, pot sherds, and other artifacts. He got intrigued, and decided to showcase the findings atop the wine cellar in a self-made museum.

If you want more details, the Washington DC CityPaper profiled Doug in a 2006 article. A good read; I recommend it.

Doug is a great guy -- pursues what he's interested in, be it homebrew, viniculture, skateboarding (he once rode the length of the C&O Canal on a self-made board -- read about it in this New York Times Magazine article), or archaeology.

Doug attended my "Walkingtown, DC" walking tour of DC's geologic history, and brought along a few odd rocks for me to identify. At the end of the tour, he invited me over to see his museum. Yesterday, I finally got the chance to do that. We cracked open a couple bottles of Dogfish Head 60-minute IPA and started browsing his collection of found prehistoric objects. Doug was very interested in my analysis of rock types (apparently archaeologists use a different set of terminology for describing what rock types projectile points are made out of).

On his own property and in neighboring areas of the Palisades, Doug has found hundreds and hundreds of objects, many of them beautifully worked arrowheads of flint, quartzite, and rhyolite. There are also some oddballs that don't fit with the human prehistory theme: a 1791 coin bearing the image of Louis XVI, crystals of amethyst and gypsum, old glass bottles, rounded river cobbles, and anything else that caught his attention. One of the most astounding things I saw yesterday was a huge woolly mammoth tooth. Doug told me a friend of his found it in the Potomac River while canoing (I think he said near Seneca Creek, but that was a beer and a half in, so maybe I've got that wrong). But there it was, a fully ridged mammoth molar; unmistakable. I hadn't heard of previous mammoth finds in our area, but I guess it's not surprising they were here.

Anyhow, I had a great time, and I recommend that everyone in the DC area make an appointment with Doug to go check out his collection and support his project.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Tuesday, May 13, 2008

Massanutten Synclinorium field trip

Last week, I mentioned some cool conglomerates I saw when NOVA adjunct instructor Chris Khourey and I did some field scouting. The main purpose of that trip was not to focus on the Culpeper Basin's boundary conglomerates, however, but the "Great Valley" of Virginia's Valley and Ridge province. The "Great Valley" is usually called the Shenandoah Valley in Virginia, because the Shenandoah River flows north through it. (Topographically, it continues north into Maryland, but the Shenandoah River isn't found there.) Sitting in the middle of the valley is a mountain range, Massanutten Mountain. And in the middle of Massanutten, there is another valley, the Fort Valley. As you can see below, Massanutten is a fence-like ridge separating the higher Fort Valley from the lower Shenandoah Valley:


In fact, rumor has it that the name "Massanutten" is a native American term for "basket." This describes the overall shape of the mountain/valley quite well. It probably won't surprise you to learn that this valley-in-a-mountain-in-a-valley pattern is due to differential weathering of folded sedimentary layers. In fact, the entire Great Valley is one big downturned fold, a syncline. Actually, it's not a perfectly smooth fold -- there are some wrinkles and minor folds within the overall down-turned structure, so we call it a synclinorium. The oldest rocks are therefore at the eastern and western edges of the Great Valley, and the youngest rocks are at the center of the Massanutten Synclinorium, up in the Fort Valley. It turns out that some of these rock layers are easily eroded, and some are tough. Of particular note is the Massanutten Sandstone, a quartz-rich, well-indurated rock that is responsible for the ridges of Massanutten Mountain. It weathers away more slowly than the shales and carbonates (limestones) above and below it. Here's a cross-section view to show how the subterranean structure influences the surface topography:

The map view up above (using Google Maps' super-cool new terrain feature) and this cross-section also show the difference in landscape texture (and geologic cause) of the Blue Ridge province in the SE corner of the images.

In discussing the geology of the area, I'm going to mix my pictures from Thursday's scouting expedition with photos from Saturday's actual field trip with my Audubon class.

Let's start at the beginning. The first stop was in the Conococheague Formation, a late Cambrian limestone. Our field trip stopped at a nice exposure near Mulberry Run, west of Strasburg, VA. Here's the crew looking close at the outcrop, and trying out their geo-interpretive field skills for the first time:

audubon_group_mulberry_run

Albert tests the outcrop with some dilute hydrochloric acid. It fizzes!

acid_albert

Soon, we spot the first of several stromatolites:

stromatolite

There are also some nice spherical grains of calcite called ooids (or ooliths). These form in wave-influenced carbonate banks today, like the Bahamas.

ooids_mulberry_run

Interpretation of this environment then? Looks like a nice passive margin, far from any major terrigenous inputs (i.e. mud or sand). Warm tropical temperatures leading to the chemical precipitation of lime mud from seawater.

What comes next? On to stop #2, the Tumbling Run section* south of Strasburg, we see a nice long exposure of the New Market, Lincolnshire, and Edinburg Formations, a series of Ordovician limestones, all dipping nicely towards the axis of the synclinorium. (Last semester, one of my Honors students looked at silicified trilobites in the Edinburg Formation.) As you walk downhill (and up-section), you see a change in the limestones. They get darker in color, and they start splitting into thin sheets along clay-rich layers. Uh-oh, we're getting an increasing clastic influence on these sedimentary rocks. They no longer record pristine, Bahamas-type environments. Now the limestone is mixing with shale. Where is all that mud coming from? A hint may be found in several bentonite layers, weathered volcanic ash deposits. There's some volcanoes getting closer to the area, it looks like.

bentonite

In the late Ordovician, the east coast of North America experienced the first of three episodes of Appalchian mountain-building. Geologists infer that the Taconian Orogeny was caused by the collision of a volcanic island arc (like modern day Indonesia) with the east coast. The Tumbling Run section shows well the increasing clastic influence of the growing Taconian Mountains to the east.

It's also good for some small but interesting tectonic structures. Check out this conjugate pair of en echelon tension gash arrays:

tension_gashes

The black nodules you see along bedding in the above image are flint nodules, very characteristic of the Lincolnshire Formation. If you get close to them, you'll find that they exhibit different mechanical properties than the limestone that surrounds them. They are more likely to break (brittle behavior) than flow (ductile behavior):

strain_flint

But let's get back to the stratigraphy, shall we? (It just doesn't do to get distracted by these minor structures!) Our next stop was to look at the Oranda Formation (calcareous shale), indicating heavy clastic influence (but still a bit of carbonate). Then, after a lovely lunch at the Strasburg Emporium, we headed off to the Buzzard Rock Trail, to look at the Martinsburg Formation. The Martinsburg is a nice thick batch of fine sand and mud interpreted as turbidite deposits. Various pieces of the Bouma sequence can be seen throughout the formation, including graded beds, ripple marks, and cross-bedding. This picture conveys these alternating lithologies, representing fluctuating current strength as turbidity currents periodically brought coarser sediment into the deep (low-oxygen, as indicated by the dark color) basin.

martinsburg_sand_shale

Now, keep in mind that all these sedimentary layers later got folded during the final phase of Appalachian mountain-building, the Alleghenian ("Alleghany") Orogeny. At that same time of intense deformation, some of these mud layers began to convert to slate. The outcrop on the Buzzard Rock Trail shows this pretty well, in spite of being covered by lichen, algae, moss, and other horrible rock-obscuring growths:

martinsburg_buzzard_rock_trail_2

The sandy layers outcrop as stiff, blocky strata. But look to the right of the quarter: in the muddy layers, a penetrative cleavage has developed, subperpendicular to the compressive stress. Here, let me draw for you what I saw at this outcrop:

martinsburg_buzzard_rock

The clay minerals in the mud are more susceptible to being alligned by tectonic forces than the grains of sand in the coarser layers. So the shaley intervals exhibit a more pronounced cleavage than do the sandy intervals.

But again, I'm getting distracted by the tectonic overprinting! This trip is supposed to be about stratigraphy, pure and simple. Doggone it! Okay, moral of the Martinsburg: no more carbonate by the late Ordovician. Instead, this sedimentary basin is getting filled with clastic debris shed off the Taconian Mountains** to the east.

Next layer up is the Massanutten Formation: mainly quartz sandstone, but also some quartz pebble conglomerate. We see it by entering the "basket" via a water gap near Waterlick, VA. Driving south (uphill) along Passage Creek, we were soon surrounded by looming cliffs of quartzite. It represents fluvial and beach facies as the depositional basin was filled to the brim. Here's a boulder of the conglomeratic portion:

massanutten_conglomerate

Here's some nice cross-beds in the sandy portion exposed near Blue Hole, about 4 miles south of Waterlick, VA:

crossbeds_massanutten

Other Massanutten Formation features include some fossils. Here's some poorly-preserved brachiopod external molds:

brach_molds

And here's some Arthophycus horizontal trace fossils, probably made by polycheate worms:

arthrophycus2

Okay, I can't resist this tectonic structure: an awesome anticline exposed along the Veatch Gap Trail (eastern part of the synclinorium, where a small anticline in the Massanutten Formation is superimposed on the larger synclinal pattern):

anticline_massanutten

Beyond the Massanutten Formation, we are in the Fort Valley proper, inside the "canoe" shape of the Massanutten Mountain ridge system. Next layer up is some upper Silurian / lower Devonian carbonates, representing a return to passive margin sedimentation after the end of the Taconian Orogeny and the erosional beveling of those ancient mountains. Unfortunately, there are no good places to stop on the narrow Fort Valley Road, so I don't have a picture of them to share. Trust me, though: they're there.

The next good stops are of Devonian shales. There's some nice ones exposed across the road from Elizabeth Furnace. More mud? From whence does it come? We interpret this again as the onset of an orogeny, in this case the Devonian-aged Acadian Orogeny, which dumped a big thick wedge of sediment into the Appalachian Basin. Here's a shot of the Needmore Formation, one of these shales with distinctive trace fossils highlighted by iron oxide:

Needmore Formation

The overlying Mahantango Formation (Devonian) is a siltstone that bears a decent number of body fossils, like these brachiopods:

fossils

Here's something that may be the back of a trilobite (if I'm not imagining the lobe to the left of the central line of knobs), or maybe a crinoid (if the "central" line is all there is):

trilobite?

Here's what appears to be the (vertically-oriented) trace fossil Daedalus, which I learned for the first time this spring in Silurian rocks near Buffalo, New York:

Daedalus?

Finally, at the top of the stack, near Seven Fountains, there are exposures of more bentonite, in this case the Tioga Bentontite, a major stratigraphic marker bed throughout the Appalachians. Here's a shot of the bentonite exposure on the Fort Valley Road near Seven Fountains:

tioga bentonite

Here's Chris looking at the outcrop:

tioga_outcrop

To summarize the Fort Valley portion of the story: after the Taconian Orogeny ends, we get a brief period of tectonic calm and passive margin sedimentation (carbonate), and then a return to orogenically-induced clastic sedimentation (augmented with volcanic eruptions). In the sedimentary sequence of the Massanutten Synclinorium, this records the onset of the Acadian Orogeny. The actual deformation of all these sedimentary horizons into a synclinorium shape was accomplished by the Alleghenian Orogeny: the much bigger mountian-building episode triggered with Africa and North America collided in the latest Paleozoic.

Hope you enjoyed joining us on this trip. Virginia's got some great geology, eh?

* For the Tumbling Run section, I highly recommend this excellent field guide:
Fichter, Lynn S., and Diecchio, Richard J., 1986, "The Taconic sequence in the northern Shenandoah Valley, Virginia." In: Geological Society of American Centennial Field Guide - Southeastern Section, p.73-78.

** Note I don't say "Taconic." The Taconic Mountains are a modern topographic feature in New York. They exhibit Taconian rocks well, and the orogeny is named for them, but the Ordovician Taconian Mountains would have been much bigger and more areally extensive.

Labels: , , , , ,